Categories
Approvals and Compliance, Environment, Environment and Planning Litigation, Environmental and Social Standards, Major Projects and Infrastructure
The Commonwealth government has released draft National Environmental Standards (NES) for Matters of National Environmental Significance (MNES).
The Commonwealth has released “final draft” NES for MNES.
The draft NES are currently unsigned by environment Minister Sussan Ley and will not come into effect until the Standards and Assurance Bill has been passed.
If the draft NES become enforceable in their current state, they will be subject to review within two years of commencing (see proposed section 65G(1) of the Standards and Assurance Bill).
The draft NES are not open for comment.
The Department of Agriculture, Water and the Environment has stated that the draft NES are intended to better facilitate single touch approval arrangements with States and Territories by ensuring that the “same rules apply, regardless of whether an approval decision is made by the Australian Government or a state or territory”.
Notwithstanding this intention, the draft NES distinguish between requirements for:
This is in contrast to the NES proposed in the Independent Review, which were intended to apply to “actions, decisions, plans and policies” under the EPBC Act.
The draft NES have do not include key aspects of the NES proposed in the Independent Review. Changes include:
Of particular note, the draft NES for the Great Barrier Reef do not adopt any aspects of the recommended NES in the Independent Review.
The draft NES do not adopt a number of aspects of the NES proposed by the Independent Review. Despite claims that the draft NES are intended to reflect the current state of the EPBC Act, a number of existing facets of the Act are not included. By way of example, the draft NES do not make any mention of considering cumulative impacts on MNES (as is currently required under the EPBC Act (see Queensland Conservation Council Inc v Minister for the Environment and Heritage [2003] FCA 1463 (Nathan Dam case)), and was proposed to be included in the NES in the Independent Review). But this does not mean that proponents will be excused from having regard to these considerations under the EPBC Act.
The introduction of the draft NES will likely provide an opportunity for decision makers to test key tenets of the Act (such as cumulative impacts) and may lead to the development of new legal precedent around these issues. This would, however, run contrary to one of the aims of the Independent Review, being to reduce so-called “lawfare” arising from challenges to decisions made under the EPBC Act.
The draft NES can be viewed here.
By Peter Briggs, Partner, Heidi Asten, Partner, Melanie Debenham, Partner, and Brigitte Rheinberger, Solicitor.
Partner, Sydney
Partner, Melbourne
Partner, Perth
Senior Associate, Sydney
Partner, Sydney
Partner, Melbourne
Partner, Perth
Senior Associate, Sydney
The articles published on this website, current at the dates of publication set out above, are for reference purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action.