Categories
No related Categories
The Hong Kong Court of Appeal has dismissed the appeal in Chu Kong v Lau Wing Yan & others [2026] HKCA 1004, affirming the striking out of a double derivative action and confirming that a contributory has no standing to bring proceedings on behalf of a company in liquidation.
Background
The Plaintiff and Defendant were former shipping business partners whose dispute led to extensive litigation in Hong Kong, the BVI and Singapore. A central issue of their dispute concerned Ocean Sino Limited (“OSL”), a BVI company jointly owned by the parties. OSL wholly owns PBM Asset Management Limited (“PBM”), a Hong Kong company, which in turn held a 49% stake in BGA Holdings Limited (“BGAH”).
Following the Defendant’s successful petition to wind up OSL on the just and equitable ground, the liquidators of OSL caused PBM to issue a statutory demand against BGAH in respect of a shareholder loan and subsequently petitioned for BGAH’s winding up in Hong Kong. The Plaintiff challenged the liquidators' conduct in the BVI and failed at first instance and on appeal. The Plaintiff then brought double derivative proceedings in Hong Kong on behalf of OSL and PBM against the Defendant and the liquidators, alleging breaches of fiduciary duties.
Decision
The Court of Appeal upheld the lower court’s decision that the Plaintiff lacked locus standi to bring the derivative action. In particular:
Comments
This decision draws a clear line: once a company enters liquidation, derivative actions are no longer available. Shareholders who believe a claim should be pursued must seek relief through the liquidation process and the court supervising the liquidation, rather than through separate proceedings.
This decision is particularly important in the context of cross-border insolvencies. The Court of Appeal confirmed that challenges to foreign-appointed liquidators should ordinarily be brought before the appointing court. Hong Kong courts will be reluctant to permit proceedings that could interfere with a recognised foreign liquidation.
For more information, please contact Jojo Fan, Managing Partner, Paul Quinn, Partner, Rachael Shek, Partner, Truman Mak, Partner, Sara Troughton, Knowledge Lawyer or your usual Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer contact.
Managing Partner, China Offices, Hong Kong
Partner, Hong Kong
Partner, Hong Kong
Partner, Hong Kong
Knowledge Lawyer, Hong Kong
The articles published on this website, current at the dates of publication set out above, are for reference purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action.