Categories
Development, Environmental law, Land use, zoning and planning
The Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2017 came into force on 16 May 2017, implementing the 2014 EU Directive. Similar regulations have also come into force under the infrastructure planning regime. Largely, the new regulations are a fairly extensive and, in places, trivial set of amendments. The question is, will they have a tangible impact on established EIA practice?
The key theme of the regulations is greater consistency and quality throughout the EIA process. Gone are some of the more ambiguous requirements. Standardisation is the order of the day.
Welcome changes? Sort of. The standardisation of procedures sets a higher bar for the provision of environmental information, which should increase the overall quality of engagement between developers, the planning authority and consultees. The checklists are more explicit and, in theory at least, greater clarity should stop time being wasted by repetition and reduce project exposure to legal challenge. Unfortunately, more explicit checklists mean longer checklists. The list of information that should be included in the ES has grown considerably. The new requirements will be subject to increased scrutiny by both decision makers and objectors, and a more forensic examination of the new procedures will be necessary. Inevitably, this will have a corresponding impact on developers' resourcing requirements.
One gets the sense that the objective of the European law makers was to ensure that nothing slips through the net. The problem is that the EIA net casts itself too wide. This blurs the line over whether the content of the ES is legally sound and increases uncertainty over whether sufficient steps have been taken to "rule out" possible impacts of development. The requirement for the decision maker to provide a "reasoned conclusion" that is "up to date" also creates uncertainty around the adequacy of the assessment. A risk-averse project promoter may feel it necessary to explore expensive, and potentially unnecessary, environmental assessments and mitigation proposals. Meanwhile, the engines are turned off and no spades hit the ground. These issues are particularly acute at the screening stage; developers could be forgiven for feeling like establishing whether they need an EIA is becoming increasingly similar to carrying out the EIA.
In fairness, the regulations now encourage applicants to submit details of measures envisaged to prevent what might have otherwise been significant adverse effects on the environment when submitting their screening request. This may encourage developers to consider mitigation or avoidance measures earlier in the project cycle, thus having the broader impact of reducing the level of projects subject to EIA.
There are some procedural changes that could catch out developers (and planning authorities) as new projects come forward:
The UK Government published the "Great Repeal Bill" on 30 March which makes arrangements for ensuring that EU-derived statutory instruments will continue to apply after the date that the UK leaves the EU. The UK Government's commitment to the Bill was reaffirmed in the Queen's Speech on 21 June. Whilst there must be some prospect of the UK seeking to reduce the burden of EIA post-Brexit, it will be necessary for developers to comply fully with the regulations in the short to medium term.
Author: James Gibson, Associate (Scotland), Planning, London
For more information please contact:
Partner, London
The articles published on this website, current at the dates of publication set out above, are for reference purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action.