Categories
Competition disputes, Competition Litigation, Digital/Data, E-COMMERCE, EUROPEAN COMMISSION, International trade, ONLINE PLATFORMS
The EU's groundbreaking Digital Markets Act (DMA) came into force on 1 November 2022 and applies from 2 May 2023. In this update we summarise key developments: the Implementing Regulation, institutional changes in DG COMP, workshops, and national proposals granting National Competition Authorities powers.
The DMA aims at improving the contestability and fairness of digital markets, by imposing obligations and prohibitions on companies that provide "core platform services" and are designated as "gatekeepers" by the European Commission.
For further details on the DMA itself, including the process and criteria under which the Commission will designate a 'gatekeeper', the obligations and prohibitions to which gatekeepers will be subject, the Commission's investigatory powers, sanctions and private enforcement, see our previous blog post here.
Most provisions of the DMA and of the Implementing Regulation apply from 2 May 2023.
From that date companies meeting the quantitative thresholds in the DMA must submit certain information to the Commission so that the Commission can designate them as 'gatekeepers'. The companies in scope have until 3 July 2023 to submit the information.
In practice, many such companies are already in pre-notification discussions with the Commission.
Following submission of the information, the Commission will then have 45 working days to designate the company as a gatekeeper. Designations are therefore likely to be around 6 September 2023 (assuming submission of the information around 3 July).
Following the Commission's designation decision, a gatekeeper will have six months to comply with the obligations and prohibitions in the DMA.
Gatekeepers must therefore be in compliance with the obligations and prohibitions by around March 2024. This is therefore the date at which enforcement may start either by the Commission or private enforcement by litigants in national courts.
In the meantime, the various stakeholders will be considering the potential changes to their businesses and engaging with the Commission including through workshops (see further below). This includes not just gatekeepers but also companies dealing with, or competing with, gatekeepers, as well as trade associations, consumer organisations etc.
On 14 April 2023 the Commission adopted an Implementing Regulation for the DMA.
This deals with the procedural aspects of the DMA, including notifications and submissions of information, the protection of confidential information, access to file and time limits.
The final version of the Implementing Regulation follows a draft published on 9 December 2022, and a short consultation over Christmas closing on 9 January 2023. The most significant change in the final version relates to access to the Commission's file (which is expanded, but still limited to the recipient of the Commission's provisional findings, with no role for the Hearing Officer or access by third parties such as complainants).
A summary of key provisions in the Implementing Regulation is below.
Articles 2, 3 and 4 deal with notifications and submissions of information.
Articles 5, 6, 7 and 8 cover conduct of proceedings.
Articles 9 and 10 concern time limits, and Article 11 procedures for the transmission and receipt of documents.
Whilst relatively short, the Implementing Regulation needs to be read alongside the DMA itself, which sets out detailed rules in relation to various procedural matters.
One notable absence from the DMA was a formal role for complainants, and thus the Implementing Regulation does not refer to them or provide them with any procedural rights.
In addition, we note that, as expected given its purpose, the Implementing Regulation does not provide substantive guidance on the DMA. It is hoped that the Commission will provide this separately.
Overall it is clear that in the Implementing Regulation the Commission is seeking to balance the need for swift enforcement of the DMA (in particular compared to antitrust enforcement) with the due process rights of gatekeepers. There is a risk that this has come at the expense of some procedural safeguards and processes, and it will be interesting to see if there is litigation on such points in future.
In order to facilitate enforcement of the DMA, the Commission has created a new directorate within DG COMP.
Directorate J on digital platforms is headed by Alberto Bacchiega and is composed of three units: Digital Platforms I (Head of Unit: Lucia Bonova), Digital Platforms II (Head of Unit: Michael Koenig) and Digital Platforms III (Head of Unit: Thomas Kramler).
These units will deal with the DMA and also antitrust investigations into platforms, indicating that the Commission sees enforcement synergies between the DMA and the Commission's traditional antitrust tools.
In addition to DG COMP, DG CNECT will play a role in the enforcement of the DMA. Dedicated teams within DG CNECT will be organised around thematic domains, including the societal, technical and economic aspects.
The Commission has stressed its desire to have an open dialogue with stakeholders in relation to the DMA, to give them the opportunity to express their views as regards the implementation and compliance.
In line with this approach, the Commission has to date organised three workshops on matters of interest to a variety of stakeholders, with a fourth to be held tomorrow.
Those to date have been well-attended by potential gatekeepers, industry representatives and consumer associations, and have been an opportunity to discuss implementation challenges and concerns.
The Commission moderated the discussions but did not provide guidance on implementation and compliance. In line with an open approach, the Commission has published materials from presenters and a recording of each workshop (see here).
The workshops to date are as follows:
• Self-preferencing (5 December 2022): The series of workshops kicked off with the DMA prohibition of self-preferencing.
• Interoperability between text messaging communications services (27 February 2023): The next workshop concerned the DMA's obligation to ensure interoperability in the case of messaging services (which is on a different timeline to other DMA obligations, being introduced in phases).
• App store provisions (6 March 2023): The third workshop dealt with obligations relevant to app stores.
• Data-related obligations (5 May 2023): An upcoming workshop will cover data-related obligations of the DMA:
The DMA is an EU Regulation (rather than a Directive) and thus does not require national implementing regulation.
However, although the Commission is responsible for the enforcement of the DMA, Member States can grant their National Competition Authorities (NCAs) powers to initiate investigations into possible non-compliance with the DMA on their territory.
To date, the German government has stated that in its 11th Amendment of the Act Against Restraints of Competition it will authorise the Bundeskartellamt to conduct investigations into cases of possible non-compliance with the DMA, and will facilitate private enforcement and align it to existing competition law private enforcement to create "a good national infrastructure for private enforcement of the DMA".
Similarly, the Netherlands government is consulting on a bill to give the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets the authority to monitor compliance with the DMA, to initiate investigations and to exchange information with the Commission. The bill also provides for other adjustments that it considers necessary for the implementation of the DMA, such as an amendment to its Code of Civil Procedure to clarify the cooperation between the Commission and courts in the Netherlands.
We expect that other Member States may also introduce legislation empowering their NCAs and facilitating private enforcement in national courts.
The next year is likely to be busy on various aspects of the DMA. Potential gatekeepers will be engaging in pre-notification discussions with the Commission, then notifying Form GD. They will also be discussing potential compliance with the Commission, as will other stakeholders. The Commission will have a busy summer considering and taking designation decisions. Gatekeepers, companies dealing with them, and their competitors, will be considering what compliance will mean for their business models and what costs and opportunities this may bring. Member States will be consulting on and legislating to give their NCAs powers to launch investigations, and if necessary to amend their court procedures in anticipation of private enforcement actions. We may also see the first litigation if gatekeepers challenge designation decisions, and once the deadline for gatekeepers' compliance with the DMA passes next March, the prospect of enforcement by the Commission or private enforcement. A busy time for all stakeholders!
If you would like to discuss these developments in more detail please get in touch with the authors or your usual contact at HSF.
Managing Partner, Competition/Antitrust, Regulation and Trade, Brussels
Of Counsel, Brussels
Managing Partner, Competition/Antitrust, Regulation and Trade, Brussels
Of Counsel, Brussels
The articles published on this website, current at the dates of publication set out above, are for reference purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action.