Categories
Tax Fraud & Penalties, Business Taxes, International Issues, HMRC Procedure
Although the offences of failure to prevent the facilitation of tax evasion have been on the statute books for eight years, HMRC has only recently secured its first charging decision. The charge, brought against Stockport-based Bennett Verby Accountants, relates to the failure to prevent the facilitation of UK tax evasion, involving alleged research and development repayment fraud. It is understood that six individuals, including one of the firm's former directors, have also been charged with offences, including cheating the public revenue and money laundering. A provisional trial date has been set for 27 September 2027.
Two corporate criminal offences were introduced by the Criminal Finances Act 2017 with effect from 30 September 2017:
The offences apply to companies, other bodies corporate and partnerships (wherever incorporated or formed). Strict liability is imposed (with no need to prove knowledge or intent on the part of senior management) where an 'associated person' of that organisation (being an employee, agent or other person providing services for or on behalf of that organisation) facilitates tax evasion.
The only defence available to an organisation is to show that (1) it had in place 'reasonable procedures' to prevent that facilitation, or (2) in all the circumstances it was not reasonable to have such procedures in place (the 'reasonable procedures defence'). Those convicted potentially face unlimited fines.
The importance of the reasonable procedures defence in avoiding a prosecution is underscored in the (recently updated) CPS/SFO joint guidance on Corporate Prosecutions. (The CPS is responsible for prosecuting the Domestic Offence, whereas the SFO is responsible for investigating and prosecuting the Foreign Offence.) That guidance makes clear that careful consideration of the availability of the reasonable procedures defence will form a critical part of assessing whether the evidential part of the test for bringing a prosecution has been satisfied. Accordingly, an organisation's ability to evidence its prevention procedures (and their reasonableness) may make the difference between the serious adverse publicity (and jeopardy) of a charging decision, and a decision to take no further action.
Following criticism last year of HMRC's failure to bring any prosecutions for the facilitation offences (including from Dame Margarat Hodge MP, who said that the lack of enforcement of the "paper tiger" law was "appalling"), HMRC now has 11 live investigations and a further 27 "live opportunities" under review (in addition to this first prosecution). These span 13 different business sectors, including software providers, labour provision, accountancy, legal services and transport.
HMRC's increased activity in relation to the facilitation offences forms part of a wider compliance effort. One of the Government's key priorities for HMRC is to close the 'tax gap' (which was said to stand at £46.8bn in 2023/24) with the stated aim of raising over £1 billion in additional gross tax revenue per year by 2029/30 (highlighted in HMRC's Spring Statement 2025). An escalation of compliance activity forms part of HMRC's plan to achieve this aim. In addition to its focus on the facilitation offences, HMRC is pursuing a number of other compliance workstreams, including:
This first prosecution of the facilitation offence evidences HMRC's willingness to pursue a case to prosecution, rather than relying solely on the offence's deterrent effect. Given the live prosecution risk, and given that the reasonable procedures defence is the only defence available, businesses should take the following actions to mitigate the risk of exposure:
The HSF Kramer tax team have extensive experience supporting clients in risk assessments, preparation of policies and procedures, and advising on instances of suspected facilitation/evasion. Please reach out to Casey Dalton, Nick Clayton, Kate Meakin or your usual HSF contact if you would like more information about this.
The articles published on this website, current at the dates of publication set out above, are for reference purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action.