An employer can fairly dismiss for gross misconduct where it has a genuine and reasonable belief (after reasonable investigation) that an employee has dishonestly exaggerated their condition and fraudulently claimed sick leave and pay. The EAT confirmed in Metroline West v Ajaj that such dishonesty is a fundamental breach of trust and confidence and may justify dismissal.
Whether dismissal is fair in any particular case will depend on the facts, including whether the employer has communicated to staff and acted consistently in relation to malingering and whether it has convincing evidence of the deceit. In some cases it may be appropriate to obtain covert evidence of activities in a public place, or review activities reported on publicly available social media. Often it will be prudent to obtain a medical opinion on what this evidence means in terms of the employee's condition.
Key contacts
Samantha Brown
Managing Partner, Employment, Pensions and Incentives, UK and EMEA, London
Steve Bell
Managing Partner, Employment, Industrial Relations and Safety, Asia and Australia, Melbourne
Emma Rohsler
Partner, Head of Employment, Pensions and Incentives, EMEA, Paris
Tim Leaver
Partner, London
Andrew Taggart
Partner, London
Fatim Jumabhoy
Partner, Head of Employment & Workplace Investigations, Asia, Singapore
Barbara Roth
Partner, New York
Christine Young
Partner, London
Disclaimer
The articles published on this website, current at the dates of publication set out above, are for reference purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action.